Why Students Get Stuck in Third Person (and How to Help Them Move Beyond It)
Modified on Fri, 19 Sep at 11:16 AM
Why do students get stuck in third person, and how can I help them move through it?
There are a few reasons why students get stuck in the third person, and there are specific things in the curriculum—and things you can add—that can help move them through it.
Why students get stuck in third person
- The “bare” verb is often closest to the 3rd person singular in Spanish, like corre (runs) or camina (walks). This is usually the first form of a verb to appear (reference: Ordered Development; see VanPatten, The Nature of Language: A Short Guide to What’s in Our Heads, ACTFL Publications, 2019). For example, the nosotros (we) form shows up for students much later in their language development than 3rd person singular or 1st person singular.
- Students tend to hear the third person form more often. It’s easier to link to meaning as it usually just means one thing (e.g. corre (runs) = runs).
What to do about it
First, acknowledge that Ordered Development tells us this is expected. Don’t stress if students take longer for the other forms to show up in their writing. If they interpret corro (I run) as “I run,” that’s a win—eventually it will show up in their writing and speaking.
Then, use tools from the curriculum to recycle core vocabulary in different ways and contexts.
Strategies to support movement beyond third person
1. Personalized Questions and Answers (PQA)
- Ask questions using the tú (you) form, and restate student responses using the yo (I) and nosotros (we) forms. This is one reason why dice (says) is introduced right away.
2. Dialogue in readings and stories
- Use or add dialogue to stories.
- After finishing a story, try a Write and Discuss written as if you are the main character. This extends the story and makes great use of como si fueras (as if you were).
- Instead of adding one character, add twins. The characters must use nosotros (we), and others must refer to them in plural.
3. Horizontal conjugation activities
- These start to appear in Unit 3. The idea is to change the perspective of the sentence (paragraph, story).
4. Games like “Who Said It?”
- This game provides more robust exposure to the yo (I) form.
Was this article helpful?
That’s Great!
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry! We couldn't be helpful
Thank you for your feedback
Feedback sent
We appreciate your effort and will try to fix the article